关于solid45和solid95单元对模态分析的影响!

浏览:182348 回答:4
我对机床床身进行模态分析,机床长13米,重15吨,内部是方孔型基本规则的筋板。为啥用solid45单元可以基本顺利的进行模态分析,但是用solid95单元模态分析老出错无果,甚至不能划分网格,用的模态提取方法都是是Block Lanczos。
有人说是单元收敛性关系啥的,有没有高手提点建议啊?例如如何设置一些分析选项啥的?谢谢
邀请回答 我来回答

全部回答

(4)
默认 最新
xiaotiaoer
SOLID95 比较精细点吧
2011年6月29日
评论 点赞
franklin1314
一般来说带中节点的二次单元分析精度高,但为什么还要用不带中节点的线性单元呢,那是因为很多分析不适合用二次单元,比如,动态分析不要用带中节点的单元(因为动态分析中涉及波的传播,而二次单元质量分布不均匀),非线性分析尽量用线性单元(因为线性单元的积分点多),所以不要一味地追求高精度而使用二次单元。
具体可以参见帮助文件:Modeling and Meshing Guide/2.2. Choosing Between Linear and Higher Order Elements/2.2.2. Quadratic Elements (Midside Nodes)
For linear structural analyses with degenerate element shapes (that is, triangular 2-D elements and wedge or tetrahedral 3-D elements), the quadratic elements will usually yield better results at less expense than will the linear elements. However, in order to use these elements correctly, you need to be aware of a few peculiar traits that they exhibit:
In dynamic analyses where wave propagation is of interest, midside-node elements are not recommended because of the nonuniform mass distribution.
A quadratic element has no more integration points than a linear element. For this reason, linear elements will usually be preferred for nonlinear analyses.
2010年4月24日
评论 点赞
franklin1314
一般来说带中节点的二次单元分析精度高,但为什么还要用不带中节点的线性单元呢,那是因为很多分析不适合用二次单元,比如,动态分析不要用带中节点的单元(因为动态分析中涉及波的传播,而二次单元质量分布不均匀),非线性分析尽量用线性单元(因为线性单元的积分点多),所以不要一味地追求高精度而使用二次单元。
具体可以参见帮助文件:Modeling and Meshing Guide/2.2. Choosing Between Linear and Higher Order Elements/2.2.2. Quadratic Elements (Midside Nodes)
For linear structural analyses with degenerate element shapes (that is, triangular 2-D elements and wedge or tetrahedral 3-D elements), the quadratic elements will usually yield better results at less expense than will the linear elements. However, in order to use these elements correctly, you need to be aware of a few peculiar traits that they exhibit:
  • In dynamic analyses where wave propagation is of interest, midside-node elements are not recommended because of the nonuniform mass distribution.
  • A quadratic element has no more integration points than a linear element. For this reason, linear elements will usually be preferred for nonlinear analyses.
2010年4月24日
评论 点赞
zhangxuewei0602
solid95是高级单元,可能造成计算量很大,所以出错
2010年4月23日
评论 点赞

没解决?试试专家一对一服务

换一批
    App下载
    技术邻APP
    工程师必备
    • 项目客服
    • 培训客服
    • 平台客服

    TOP